Deprecated: Function set_magic_quotes_runtime() is deprecated in /home/dennisfong/tsoidug.org/blog/wp-settings.php on line 18

Strict Standards: Declaration of Walker_Comment::start_lvl() should be compatible with Walker::start_lvl(&$output) in /home/dennisfong/tsoidug.org/blog/wp-includes/comment-template.php on line 0

Strict Standards: Declaration of Walker_Comment::end_lvl() should be compatible with Walker::end_lvl(&$output) in /home/dennisfong/tsoidug.org/blog/wp-includes/comment-template.php on line 0

Strict Standards: Declaration of Walker_Comment::start_el() should be compatible with Walker::start_el(&$output) in /home/dennisfong/tsoidug.org/blog/wp-includes/comment-template.php on line 0

Strict Standards: Declaration of Walker_Comment::end_el() should be compatible with Walker::end_el(&$output) in /home/dennisfong/tsoidug.org/blog/wp-includes/comment-template.php on line 0
Tsoi Dug Blog 才德博客 » Blog Archive » Confucianism and Graft 孔教和贿赂

Confucianism and Graft 孔教和贿赂

Sigh! The ignorance and arrogance of Westerners for things Chinese! This is what I found posted on Jan. 26, 2009 on Chem-PM Chinese Business Magazine, written by “admin”:

唉!西方人对中华事物真是又无知又傲慢!我找到这篇文章,刊登在2009年一月26日的 Chem-PM Chinese Business Magazine 网页上,笔者是“管理”:

Whilst the fallout from the Mattel recall still reverberates it is worth reminding ourselves about the endemic culture of corruption that pervades Chinese business… in many senses this is cultural and one should not expect Western values to be so quickly absorbed into mainstream business. With Confucianism putting loyalty to friends first t is no surprise to see an element of “capture” taking place within firms. It is fascinating to read how businesses are being advised to hire geographically dispersed workers to prevent such behavior…

美泰儿玩具的收回仍然在耳边回响时,我们应该提醒自己,中国商界充满了贪污文化在很多方面来说这是文化性的;不能以为西方价值可以这么快就被主流商界吸收。孔教是把忠于朋友放在首位的,所以见到企业里发生一种“擒获”,不应该觉得出乎意料之外。 很有趣,阅读到人们对各企业建议,要防止这种行为,就得聘请来自散布于各地区的工人

…Ιt іs еven harder to dеal wіth lowеr-lеvel shadiness, ѕuch аs a secretary booking a flight for hеr boѕs аnd thеn getting a payment from thе travel аgent, or a receptionist getting pаid to rеfer nеw enquiries to a rіval fіrm.

处理底层的不轨行为,例如秘书为上司订了飞机票,旅行社就送钱给她,或接待员受赂,把询问者介绍去竞争对手公司等,就更加困难。

I wrote the following comment:

I strongly disagree with your assertion that Confucianism means loyalty to family and friends first, and obeying the law is optional. Of the five traditional Confucian Cardinal Relations (wu lun), that between the government and the citizen comes first, before any other. So treating compliance with the law as optional is not an example of how China operates according to Confucianism, but is instead an example of how far modern China has strayed from Confucianism. As for the secretary taking a kickback from the travel agency she books with, graft is graft and embezzlement is embezzlement, Chinese or not. Again, Confucianism is quite clear on this: honesty and trustworthiness ranks extremely high on Confucian tenets, and again the prevalence of graft is just another example of how far modern China has strayed from Confucianism.

我写下这个评语:

我强烈反对你的断言,说孔教就是首先忠于家庭和朋友,而遵守法律是可以任意选择的。传统孔教的五个基本关系(五伦)中的第一个,就是政府与公民(君臣)的关系,比其他关系都排先。把遵守法律看作是可以任意选择的,不是中国沿着孔教运行的例子,而是现代中国脱离了孔教多么遥远的例子。至于秘书从订飞机票的旅行社拿到回扣,贿赂就是贿赂,盗窃就是盗窃,中国与否都一样。孔教对此很清楚,诚实和守信在孔教信条中地位非常崇高,而贿赂的风行只不过证明了现代的中国是多么严重地脱离了孔教。

Go here for more exposition of the true Confucian position on honesty and trustworthiness.

请到这里观看孔教对诚实和守信的立场。

- Feng Xin-ming 冯欣明


Please click to see: My Website, All Blog Entries, or The Latest Blog Entries.

请点击观看:我的网站所有博客贴文、或最新贴文


Web Design


Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

2 Responses to “Confucianism and Graft 孔教和贿赂

  1. Ji Says:

    I think the communist party ruined much of the traditional Chinese value. The system is so corrupted that few of the bad business men were punished for their wrong doings. For example, in the last year’s Chinese milk power scandal, the how milk industry was making that wrong doings, but only a handful people were actually punished. And some angry parents wanted to bring the power producers to the court, but the court, guided by the communist party, did not allow people to sue.

    Another point.
    Your commented: “Of the five traditional Confucian Cardinal Relations (wu lun), that between the government and the citizen comes first, before any other. So treating compliance with the law as optional is not an example of how China operates according to Confucianism, but is instead an example of how far modern China has strayed from Confucianism.”

    I think it might not be very accurate to call the people citizens in Kong’s age, because the people were more like half-slaves. It seems to me that 儒家 did not put law in priority; it was 法家 made the point that law is the most important tool to rule people. But even 法家‘s law is from the view point of the rulers, not the people. So it is still far from the ‘rule of law’ we normally refer to.

  2. admin Says:

    Thank you for your insightful comment. I don’t think that we need to agree on every exact detail regarding what happened two thousand plus years ago in order to agree that first, today, the Confucian relationship between the government and the citizens includes the citizens obeying the law, and second, Confucianism does not advocate that the citizens disregard law and treat it as optional.

Leave a Reply